The Resilience of Western Companies in Russia: Navigating Challenges Amidst Political Tensions
When Russia initiated its invasion of Ukraine, numerous global companies swiftly responded by announcing their plans to withdraw from Russia.
|"Illustration of Online Shopping (Unsplash)."|
When Russia initiated its invasion of Ukraine, numerous global companies swiftly responded by announcing their plans to withdraw from Russia. Other companies limited imports or new investments. Billions of dollars' worth of factories, energy assets, and power plants were either eliminated or sold, accompanied by strong condemnation of the war and expressions of solidarity with Ukraine. However, over a year later, an interesting reality unfolded: Leaving Russia was not as straightforward as it appeared in the initial announcements.
Navigating Obstacles: The Russian Exit Process
According to an Associated Press report, Russia has imposed obstacles on companies seeking to exit. Companies wishing to leave require approval from government commissions and, in some cases, from President Vladimir Putin himself, while facing painful discounts and taxes on selling prices. While each company's story varies, a common theme is the need to navigate between Western sanctions and public anger on one side, along with Russia's efforts to prevent and penalize departures on the other. Some international brands, such as Coke and Apple, informally entered through third-party countries despite having made decisions to exit. Many companies remained silent, occasionally citing responsibilities to shareholders, employees, or legal obligations to local franchisees or partners. Others argue that they provide essential needs such as food, agricultural supplies, or medications. One of these companies is the Italian fashion chain Benetton, whose store in Moscow is now ironically named Evropeisky Mall, meaning "Europe" in Russian.
The Persistence of Western Brands in Russia
Amidst the ongoing political tensions, Western brands continue to thrive in the Russian market, finding ways to adapt and survive.
Retailers Maintain Presence Despite Challenges
Evropeisky Mall, previously known as Benetton, bustles on weekday evenings, with customers browsing and employees tidying stacks of brightly colored clothing. At the Italian lingerie retailer Calzedonia, shoppers peruse socks and swimwear. For consumers in Moscow, the range of available products remains largely unchanged. Although the Mothercare baby products store has become Mother Bear under new local ownership, most items in the Evropeisky Mall store still bear the Mothercare brand. Alik Petrosyan, a student who shops at Maag, the former flagship Zara store in Moscow, noticed, "The quality hasn't changed at all; everything remains the same. The prices haven't changed much, considering the inflation and economic scenarios that occurred last year."
The Early Exodus: Major Industries and Key Players
The initial exodus from Russia was led by major automakers, oil companies, technology firms, and professional services. BP, Shell, ExxonMobil, and Equinor terminated joint ventures or divested billions in shares. McDonald's sold its 850 restaurants to local franchisees, while Renault France acquired a symbolic ruble for its majority stake in Avtovaz, Russia's largest car manufacturer.
Shifting Strategies: Waiting, Asset Struggles, and Business as Usual
As the initial wave of departures subsided, new categories emerged: companies waiting for the right timing, companies struggling to divest assets, and others attempting to continue business as usual.
Voluntary Business Restrictions
More than 1,000 international companies openly state that they voluntarily impose business restrictions on Russia beyond what is mandated by sanctions, according to a database maintained by Yale University.
While Russia's invasion of Ukraine initially triggered a wave of Western companies announcing their departure, the reality of exiting the country has proven more complex. The Russian government has erected obstacles, requiring approvals and imposing financial burdens on those seeking to leave. Nevertheless, many companies have found ways to continue operating in Russia, either
by adapting to the circumstances or by emphasizing their contribution to essential goods and services. As the political landscape evolves, the resilience and adaptability of Western companies in Russia will undoubtedly continue to shape the business landscape amidst ongoing tensions.